The Hidden Danger: What You Need to Know About Rising Insurance Rates

Dan Nicholson

Among the many challenges in today’s economic landscape, a quiet but significant issue is affecting household finances nationwide — the relentless increase in insurance costs. As insurance companies respond to more frequent extreme weather events and the rising costs of rebuilding, the expense is being passed on to individual homeowners. This added pressure, at a time when many Americans are already feeling a financial squeeze, may foreshadow wider economic consequences.

What’s Driving the Increase in Insurance Premiums?

Homeowners and renters have been faced with surging insurance costs in recent years, with a staggering 21% average increase in premiums in just one year between May 2022 to May 2023. With no indications that the soaring prices will slow anytime soon, insurance prices could push some homeowners’ budgets over the edge.

One major driver in the rising costs is inflation. Escalating repair costs have pushed insurance companies to adjust their premiums to accommodate losses. The pandemic years saw a 55% surge in rebuilding and replacement costs from 2019 to 2022, according to insurance companies. This was caused both by the rising price of materials and by supply chain disruptions and labor shortages.

However, another equally powerful force has been propelling the surge in insurance premiums: the growing impact of climate change. An increase in natural disasters has forced reinsurers to adjust their rates, which then has a knock-on effect on all policies.

According to data from the National Centers for Environmental Information, the U.S. experienced 25 climate disaster events so far in 2023, each resulting in losses surpassing $1 billion. This number represents a stark increase from the yearly average of 8.1 events from 1980-2022.

The combination of the climate crisis and rising inflation has created a perfect storm for insurance rates. Homeowners now face added financial strain, at a time when their budgets may already be nearing a breaking point.

How are Rising Premiums Affecting Individuals?

The surge in insurance premiums is a nationwide trend impacting homeowners and renters alike. As major investments like homes and even cars become increasingly costly to insure, the strain on household budgets is concerning. This comes on top of other post-pandemic financial considerations, such as the resumption of student loan payments and generally diminished savings accounts.

Insurance companies have felt the squeeze in recent years, too. U.S. insurers paid out $99 billion in weather-related claims in 2022. Not surprisingly, they are responding to the escalating losses by raising prices. 

Many companies have even gone so far as to decline new insurance policies in certain areas that present too much risk. This footprint of “uninsurable areas” is expanding in all states, though some are more affected than others. California, Florida, and Louisiana have been hit especially hard due to the heightened risk of hurricanes and wildfires. 

In Florida, major insurers have practically exited the market, leaving homeowners with few options and premiums nearly four times higher than the national average. California is witnessing similar challenges, with industry giants like State Farm and Allstate halting the issuance of new homeowners policies due to heightened wildfire risks. 

The withdrawal of Allstate and State Farm, coupled with the financial turmoil of smaller insurers, has left residents in certain states with severely limited insurance options. More people are now turning to state-supported insurers of last resort, where they often pay higher premiums for narrower coverage.

The financial implications of these rising premiums are significant. Projections for 2024 indicate that Americans will pay over $13 billion in insurance costs next year. As insurance becomes an increasingly burdensome aspect of the household budget, the potential for economic strain looms large.

What Are the Broader Economic Implications?

As consumers’ budgets are squeezed, they may be forced to reconsider their spending on non-essential items. The ripple effect could be far-reaching, with sectors like entertainment, travel, and services facing reduced consumer spending. 

Experts like Tim Quinlan, a senior economist at Wells Fargo, point to the impact this may have on the economy as a whole. In an interview with Business Insider, he explained that consumer spending is an important impulse that keeps the economy going. With many families’ savings already dwindling after the pandemic years, people are left “more vulnerable to a disruption like homeowners insurance costs."

While the $74 billion surge in insurance costs nationwide in 2022 represents only about 0.4% of total consumer spending, economists are expressing growing concern about potential microeconomic consequences. The people who are likely to be hit hardest include those on fixed incomes, owners of older houses, and residents in high-risk areas.

The road ahead presents challenges that demand strategic solutions. The higher burden on certain demographics raises alarms about wider economic disruption. Potential measures that have been suggested to counteract this include government intervention to mediate costs to consumers.


The soaring cost of insurance demonstrates that individuals are vulnerable to price hikes made by big companies, and some may be left in dire situations. At the same time, it shows us that insurance companies are also vulnerable to bigger systematic changes caused by climate change and inflation. Without government intervention, Americans may face severe impacts on their personal finances. For the moment, individuals will need to mitigate risks where they can by planning ahead and making strategic financial decisions. Insurance costs and other effects of inflation and climate change should be considered in any risk calculation or business decision. In the long run, there may be a need for proactive government intervention to help the country weather this economic storm.



CNN Business

National Centers for Environmental Information

New York Times

Business Insider

This article was originally published in Certainty News: Article Link

Dan Nicholson is the author of “Rigging the Game: How to Achieve Financial Certainty, Navigate Risk and Make Money on Your Own Terms,” deemed a best-seller by USA Today and The Wall Street Journal. In addition to founding the award-winning accounting and financial consulting firm Nth Degree CPAs, Dan has created and run multiple small businesses, including Certainty U and the Certified Certainty Advisor program.

No items found.
Nth Degree - Safari Dan
Next Up In
Nth Degree - Safari Dan
Pinnacle Chiropractic (Mid)
Banner for Certainty Tools, Play your Game.  Blue gradient color with CertaintyU Logo
No items found.
Nth Degree - Safari Dan
Pinnacle Chiropractic (Mid)